A MESSAGE TO NHL GENERAL MANAGERS:

So the NHL will hold their General Managers' meetings in Florida, where they will, much to the delight of the fine folks at The Hockey News, discuss fighting in hockey. Yippee.
This is in the wake of the Don Sanderson tragedy. Sanderson was playing for the Whitby (Ontario) Dunlops in the Major Hockey League. Sanderson was in a fight during a game, and his helmet came off. He fell backwards and his head hit the ice. He suffered massive damage to his frontal lobes, and was essentially brain-dead on the ice.
A few days later, Sanderson died when his family had the miserable task of taking him off life support.
By all accounts, Sanderson was a stand-up guy, which are, thankfully, in plentiful supply throughout the hockey community. But with THN calling yet again for a ban on hockey fights, it's time to take a deep breath.
Is fighting bad for hockey? Hell no it isn't. First of all, hockey, more than any other sport, is self-policing. Players are less apt to take liberties with their sticks or elbows if they know there's a knuckle sandwich waiting for them. There's a lot happening on the ice, and the officials can't see it all. Baseball used to have the deterrent of brushbacks and fastballs to the ribs. As baseball did away with this, you've seen the decline in sportsmanship, with everyone preening after a home run. But lets leave that for those who cover baseball. Let's get back to hockey.
Aside from the retribution side of fighting, let's look at the fans. There are only two times fans come out of their seats at a hockey game: goals and fights. Next time you're at a game, when the gloves hit tie ice, see how many people stay seated, or look away. Look at the benches. I think hockey fights can get more people on their feet than a holy water spinkler in Lourdes.
Now, back to Sanderson...what if he was on a breakaway, and he lost an edge on his skate, and his helmet came off and he hit his head on the ice? Would THN call for a ban to breakaways? Also, if you asked the editorial board at THN to name the greatest players of all time, the list would include names like Orr, Howe, Hull, Messier, Richard, Shore. All guys who were pretty handy with the fists.
You can go back 80 years, and hear stories about how badass the Cleghorne brothers were. It's always been a part of the game, always will be. But any time a hockey fight goes wrong, you can count on THN getting damp in the drawers at the idea of ending hockey fights.
If the NHL wants to get serious in the wake of the Sanderson tragedy, they'll look into tougher guidelines for helmets, especially chinstraps. Also, they'd look for ways to crack down on head shots.
Leave fighing alone.
Relax.




They definitely should not get rid of fighting, but policing and enforcing is a thing of the past. Goons only fight other goons. Having Georges LaRaque on the Blackhawks won't stop another team from putting clean hits on Kane to take him out of the game.
Reply to this
Clean hits aren't designed to take guys out of a game, they're designed to knock him off the puck.
The cheap shots will increase without some sort of physical presence to serve as a deterrent.
As far as the classic hockey goon goes, you won't see them as much any more, since teams can't carry 5 extra guys to dress for games where more fists might be needed. You need guys who can skate regular shifts and keep guys honest. They'll show up, count on it.
Reply to this
I wasn't trying to say clean hits are solely designed to take guys out of games. I'm just saying if a team can gameplan to control a small star like Kane by being physical with him, no fighter is going to keep the other team honest. The handful of frightening enforcers only get challenged by other enforcers. Best way to "police" in the NHL is to answer with big clean hits of your own, not fighting.
Reply to this
There is no truth to the rumor that the photo of the Frankie Says Relax girl is actually a picture of carloszno1fan from CT's collection.
Take it from a guy who sits in the penalty box with a lot of fighters: fights usually occur as a way to fire a team up who is having a slow start in a game. To a much lesser extent, there will also be an occasional spontaneous brawl over a perceived "dirty hit". But it has changed the past 3-4 years, especially at the upper levels.
Reply to this
I can't tell. Does she have nice tits?
Reply to this
She has tits. For most of our readers, that's enough.
Reply to this
Ok. Fair enough
Reply to this